Bowling for Columbine: Best Documentary or Best Fraud?
A partial list of Michael Moore’s fabrications
|
What Bowling represents |
The facts |
1. |
The Lockheed-Martin plant near Columbine makes nuclear missiles. |
• The plant does not make nuclear missiles. It makes rockets for launching satellites. |
2. |
The NRA insensitively scheduled a meeting in Denver shortly after the Columbine shooting. Charlton Heston then made defiant remarks directed at the mayor and others. |
• The Denver event was the annual NRA meeting, whose place and date had been fixed years in advance. • The NRA canceled all events (normally several days of committee meetings, sporting events, dinners, and rallies) save the annual members’ meeting, which corporate law required to be held. • The “from my cold dead hands” remark was from a speech given a year later in North Carolina. Moore juxtaposes it with footage from the Denver speech to make them seem like the same speech. • Moore splices together sentences from different parts of the Denver speech, cutting out conciliatory remarks by Heston and changing the meaning of the remarks shown. |
3. |
The NRA held a pro-gun rally in Flint, Michigan just after the shooting death of a child in a local classroom. |
• The meeting was a “get out the vote” rally, which took place eight months later, during the election season. |
4. |
The NRA is a racist organization, associated with the KKK. |
• The NRA was founded by former Union Army officers who fought a war to end slavery. Civil War veteran Maj. Gen. Ambrose Burnside was the NRA’s first president. • The U.S. President who signed the act making the Klan an illegal organization was later elected the NRA's eighth president—Ulysses S. Grant. • After Grant's term, the NRA elected General Philip Sheridan, who had removed the governors of Texas and Lousiana for failure to oppose Klan terror. • During the 1950s and 1960s, groups of blacks organized as NRA chapters in order to obtain surplus military rifles to fight off Klansmen. |
5. |
After discussing military assistance to various countries, Bowling asserts that the U.S. gave $245 million in aid to the Taliban in 2000 and 2001, and then shows aircraft hitting the twin towers to illustrate the result. |
• The aid was humanitarian assistance, given through UN and nongovernmental organizations, to relieve famine in Afghanistan. |
6. |
Bowling flashes a dramatic count of gun homicides in various countries. Moore later says that the United States has “the highest murder rate.” |
• South Africa has the highest murder rate in the world (twelve times greater than America’s). • The U.S. murder rate is lower than the world average (5.5 versus 8.5 per 100,000 population). • Many of Moore’s figures appear to be invented. |
7. |
Charlton Heston is a racist. |
• Heston worked with Martin Luther King in the civil rights movement. He led the actors’ component of MLK’s 1963 March on Washington. |
8. |
School shootings are a major problem. |
• Three times as many people die from being struck by lightning. |
Sources:
Wall Street Journal editorial on Moore.